Friday, January 27, 2012

Is the net all that and a bag of chips?

The first assigned blog for my class is to post on the impact of the internet on society.  We had to discuss this within our online forums first, but we could get specific and focus on education, or politics, or the economy.  It was so interesting to see the ‘glass half-full’ comments on how the internet has improved every facet of life.  Granted, this is an undergrad class, so many of my classmates still wear rose-colored glasses, and look largely at the internet as an entertainment vehicle.  Maybe that isn’t being fair to them, but it is a generalization that I’m making regardless.  I couldn’t resist playing the antagonistic old guy, and I had to ask questions like: does free access to information come at a price to society? What is the cost of young children accessing inappropriate content? What is the cost of porn and online dating services to marriages? What is the cost of ecommerce to local business and local economy? What is the cost of torrents to copyright holders?  Now, this blog should be evidence that I like sharing online, but I don’t think that vague statements like “the internet has improved society” are even rational.  I’ll go as far as saying that the internet has improved my quality of life in many ways, but to say that it has actually made society better?  I’m not quite there.  Has it helped develop a global economy? Sure.  Does it give access to information to those who might not otherwise have it?  Absolutely.  Does it help collaboration and sharing? Yes.  However, the Census Bureau states that only 43 percent of Americans they classify as poor have internet access.  I wonder if that 43 percent think society is much improved because of the net.  And at the risk of sounding like I’m too far left, I’ll end there.

1 comment:

  1. The only strong case against the internet not improving society would be to argue that ignorance truly is bliss. I guess for some that may be true. The fact that some people don't have it has no bearing on whether or not it has improved society.

    Of course access to information comes at a price, Freedom is not free. The alternative is to have someone else make the choice of what is or is not good for us. There are plenty of societies out there that will accommodate that request. I for one, would not care to live in one of those.

    ReplyDelete